Car 54, Where Are You? S02 E14 Stop Thief

"Patrolmen Toody and Muldoon are at the wheel, which means Car 54 could be anywhere!"

After overhearing the Captain rehearsing a play in his office, the boys think he's a kleptomaniac! They "cover" for him by re-stealing all his Xmas presents. Can they make things right by the end of Christmas Eve?