Are You Afraid of the Dark? S02 E01 The Tale of the Final Wish

"Submitted for the approval of the Midnight Society, I call this story..."

Jill is a thirteen year old that still loves things her peers have grown out of, such as unicorns and fairy tales. One night she wishes that she could be in a fairy tale world forever. After her wish is granted, she finds that living in a fairy tale isn't as happy as she'd once imagined.