Winterset Backdrop Blur
Winterset Poster

Winterset

A man is determined to find the real culprit behind the crime for which his father was wrongly executed.

Top Cast

  • Burgess Meredith

    Burgess Meredith

    Mio Romagna

  • Margo

    Margo

    Miriamne Esdras

  • Eduardo Ciannelli

    Eduardo Ciannelli

    Trock Estrella

  • Maurice Moscovitch

    Maurice Moscovitch

    Esdras

  • John Carradine

    John Carradine

    Bartolomio Romagna

  • Edward Ellis

    Edward Ellis

    Judge Gaunt

  • Paul Guilfoyle

    Paul Guilfoyle

    Garth Esdras

  • Stanley Ridges

    Stanley Ridges

    Shadow

  • Mischa Auer

    Mischa Auer

    Radical

Overview

A man is determined to find the real culprit behind the crime for which his father was wrongly executed.

Rating

6.0 / 10
18 Reviews
1 Popular

1 Reviews

  • CinemaSerf
    CinemaSerf
    6 Aug 7, 2025

    I thought Burgess Meredith turned in quite a characterful performance in this otherwise rather dry drama. He is “Mio” whose late father we have already seen at the top of the film being condemned to the chair for his part in a robbery. Now, a generation later he is determined to prove that he was innocent. What quickly becomes apparent is that the investigation at the time was largely based around the “if your face fits” theory, and it doesn’t take “Mio” very long to get onto the trail of a far more likely culprit. Meantime, we also discover that a speech made by his dad upon sentencing declaring his innocence and warning the judge that his will be a sort of living death from now on has turned out to be eerily true. That judge (Edward Ellis) has indeed somewhat lost the plot, and is a ghost of his former self wandering the streets with little memory of who he is or was. It might well be that “Mio” could be in a position to salvage more than one should here? The plot clearly seeks to highlight the difficulties for the poverty stricken, slum-dwelling, population of the USA to not just get by in life, but to get a fair hearing from authority. That’s not just the court proceedings, but also far more rudimentary aspects of freedom. Even an assembly to dance attracts the police. Ultimately, though, it really does come down to a straightforward style of good and evil, and with the underplayed but effectively sinister effort from Eduardo Ciannelli and a really quite impactful one from Ellis, this can at times be quite a poignant evaluation. Alfred Santelli hasn’t done so much to creatively adapt it from the stage though, and that straight transfer to celluloid sees it lose quite a bit of it’s intensity. Even with the romantic attachment to “Miriamne” (Margo), much of the intimacy is gone, the dialogue is all too often delivered as if it were set-piece monologues, and none of the characters really come together until very near the end. Just taking it from the theatre to the cinema was always going to compromise some of the nuance, and though this is still a decent effort it just misses a little of the story’s soul.

Recommendations

Blue Story

Blue Story is a tragic tale of a friendship between Timmy and Marco, two young boys from opposing postcodes. Timmy, a shy, smart, naive and timid young boy from Deptford, goes to school in Peckham where he strikes up a friendship with Marco, a charismatic, streetwise kid from the local area. Although from warring postcodes, the two quickly form a firm friendship until it is tested and they wind up on rival sides of a street war. Blue Story depicts elements of Rapman's own personal experiences and aspects of his childhood.

Blue Story

7.3 2019